Should We Pay Teachers the Same as Legislators?
Should We Pay Teachers the Same as Legislators?
California’s initiative process is imperfect. We cherish the right to circulate citizen’s petitions when the Legislature refuses to act on matters of critical importance.
But give any Californian the right to submit a ballot measure, and you’re sure to have some wild ideas in the bunch.
The latest is a measure to raise teacher pay to the salary levels earned by state legislators, roughly $105,000 a year. Its chief proponent, Marc Litchman, is the head of an education non-profit called California Trust for Public Schools, a former Congressional candidate and longtime Democrat staffer.
He told the Los Angeles Times that, “what we’re asking teachers to do is every bit as critical as what we’re asking legislators to do.”
Teacher salaries in California vary by community. According to the California Department of Education, state teacher salaries range from about $41,000 in small districts with fewer than 1,000 students to about $96,000 at the highest levels for high school teachers in districts with more than 4,000 students.
The devil, of course is in the details. In this case, it’s the funding mechanism – a 2-cent increase in the state sales tax.
That’s likely a non-starter in over-taxed California. The statewide sales tax is 7.25 percent, and many localities have enacted local increases on top of that, running as high as 10.25 percent in some cities in Los Angeles County.
Most people would favor knocking Sacramento politicians down a peg or two, but not if it would raise their out-of-pocket costs every time they buy something.
Litchman’s proposal is also missing a key component – any consideration of teacher effectiveness. Under a blanket salary increase, there would be no consideration whether those teachers are effective and deserving of a raise.
The landmark Vergara case, while unsuccessful, brought to light how lack of teacher accountability and poor teacher performance – especially in inner-city schools where good teachers are needed the most – are hurting students.
As my colleague Lance Izumi wrote last year in Fox and Hounds:
Beatriz Vergara, the high school student from Pacoima who was the named plaintiff in the case, testified that her seventh-grade history teacher made “rude comments.” How rude? According to Beatriz, her teacher “would call us stupid and tell us that we’re going [to] clean houses for a living, and that Latinos are going to end up being ‘cholos.’”
Elizabeth Vergara, sister of Beatriz, testified that her eighth-grade English class covered one chapter of an assigned book over the course of an entire year.
Are these ineffective, and in some cases offensive, teachers deserving of a raise? They probably would get one if Litchman’s measure becomes law.
Many individuals submit ballot proposals and come nowhere near collecting the required number of signatures to make the ballot. With so many electoral fights looming in 2018, most potential supporters will probably pick their battles elsewhere.
Litchman’s proposal is destined to join the list of many well-meaning ballot proposals that are simply unworkable and unrealistic and will never become reality.
Tim Anaya is communications director for Pacific Research Institute.
This article is republished with permission from our friends at the Pacific Research Institute
Utah Standard News depends on the support of readers like you.
Good Journalism requires time, expertise, passion and money. We know you appreciate the coverage here. Please help us to continue as an alternative news website by becoming a subscriber or making a donation. To learn more about our subscription options or make a donation, click here.
To Advertise on UtahStandardNews.com, please contact us at: ed@utahstandardnews.com.
Comments - One Response to “Should We Pay Teachers the Same as Legislators?”
Pings:
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Comments:
”raise teacher pay to the salary levels earned by state legislators” Why limit it to legislators pay? Why limit to teacher? Why not raise Judges pay to the salary of athletes, or celebrities? Why not raise Teachers pay to college high paid employees? How many Justices is a job worth?
2010 annual salary for the (1) Chief Justice is $223,500 per year, while the (8) Associate Justices each make $213,900.
Consider Oprah Winfrey, a Media personality actor made $315 Million which would hire 1,479 Justices (The entire Article III Judicial Branch) or (The entire Administrartive Law Judges corps plus.)
Next consider David Letterman, formerThe Late Show host actor CBS, made $28 Million a year, the equivalent of salaries of 131 Justices (All Authorized Judges for 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th, 8th, 9th circuits of the US Court of Appeals)
Or, Conan O’Brien, Actor TBS TV made $10 million a year , the salary of 47 Justices, or 200 teachers.
Or the following college coaches. (figures circa 2010)
1. Nick Saban Alabama SEC $5,166,666 (equal to about 103 teachers)
2. Mack Brown Texas Big 12 $5,100,000
3. Bob Stoops Oklahoma Big 12 $4,275,000
4. Urban Meyer Florida SEC $4,010,000
5. Kirk Ferentz Iowa Big Ten $3,775,000
6. Les Miles Louisiana State SEC $3,751,000
7. Jim Tressel Ohio State Big Ten $3,512,000
8. Jim Grobe Wake Forest ACC $2,939,475
9. Mark Richt Georgia SEC $2,811,340
10. Bobby Petrino Arkansas SEC $2,700,000
11. Gary Pinkel Missouri Big 12 $2,550,000
12. Rich Rodriguez Michigan Big Ten $2,515,180
13. Houston Nutt Mississippi SEC $2,500,000
14. Chip Kelly Oregon Pac-10 $2,400,000
15. Jeff Tedford California Pac-10 $2,300,000
15. Paul Johnson Georgia Tech ACC $2,300,000
17. June Jones Southern Methodist CUSA $2,142,056
18. Derek Dooley Tennessee SEC $2,118,391
19. Gene Chizik Auburn SEC $2,100,000
19. Turner Gill Kansas Big 12 $2,100,000
22. Frank Beamer Virginia Tech ACC $2,043,000
23. Ralph Friedgen Maryland ACC $2,036,306
24. Steve Spurrier South Carolina SEC $2,000,000
25. Mike Gundy Oklahoma State Big 12 $1,925,000
26. Greg Schiano Rutgers Big East $1,895,000
27. Bill Snyder Kansas State Big 12 $1,875,000
28. Steve Sarkisian Washington Pac-10 $1,850,004
29. Jimbo Fisher Florida State ACC $1,800,000
29. Mike Sherman Texas A&M Big 12 $1,800,000
31. Mark Dantonio Michigan State Big Ten $1,796,700
32. Mike London Virginia ACC $1,780,000
33. Butch Davis North Carolina ACC $1,752,000
34. Dabo Swinney Clemson ACC $1,750,000
35. Joker Phillips Kentucky SEC $1,700,000
35. Skip Holtz South Florida Big East $1,700,000
35. Bret Bielema Wisconsin Big Ten $1,700,000
38. Gary Patterson Texas Christian MWC $1,642,089
39. Charlie Strong Louisville Big East $1,600,000
40. David Cutcliffe Duke ACC $1,581,903
41. Randy Edsall Connecticut Big East $1,550,000
42. Ron Zook Illinois Big Ten $1,505,000
43. Dennis Erickson Arizona State Pac-10 $1,500,000
43. Tommy Tuberville Texas Tech Big 12 $1,500,000
45. Chris Petersen Boise State WAC $1,489,053
46. Dan Hawkins Colorado Big 12 $1,383,903
47. George O’Leary Central Florida CUSA $1,325,754
48. Rick Neuheisel UCLA Pac-10 $1,250,000
49. Dan Mullen Mississippi State SEC $1,200,000
50. Kyle Whittingham Utah MWC $1,175,000
51. Mike Riley Oregon State Pac-10 $1,110,000
52. Joe Paterno Penn State Big Ten $1,109,977
53. Greg McMackin Hawaii WAC $1,100,004
54. Mike Stoops Arizona Pac-10 $1,100,000
54. Butch Jones Cincinnati Big East $1,100,000
56. Paul Rhoads Iowa State Big 12 $1,050,000
57. Dave Wannstedt Pittsburgh Big East $1,010,873
58. Kevin Sumlin Houston CUSA $1,000,000
59. Pat Hill Fresno State WAC $952,499
60. Ken Niumatalolo Navy Independent $926,434
61. Bill Stewart West Virginia Big East $903,000
62. Danny Hope Purdue Big Ten $900,000
63. Art Briles Baylor Big 12 $878,315
64. Dave Christensen Wyoming MWC $861,000
65. Tim Brewster Minnesota Big Ten $808,000
66. Todd Graham Tulsa CUSA $804,253
67. Ruffin McNeill East Carolina CUSA $792,241
68. Larry Porter Memphis CUSA $750,000
68. Mike Locksley New Mexico MWC $750,000
70. Troy Calhoun Air Force MWC $725,000
71. Steve Fairchild Colorado State MWC $700,000
72. Larry Fedora Southern Mississippi CUSA $685,000
73. Brady Hoke San Diego State MWC $675,000
74. Bill Lynch Indiana Big Ten $650,000
75. Tom O’Brien North Carolina State ACC $632,950